Skip to content
Mapleton, Utah
Morkel Financial & Tax Services

Seller financing rental property taxes: the gain spreads, the rate does not.

By Ewan Morkel, EA6 min read

The rumor is that depreciation recapture comes due the year you close and kills the installment sale. For a straight-line residential rental that is wrong, but the ordering rule in Treas. Reg. §1.453-12 loads the 25% layer into your first payments, and a cost segregation study really does put recapture back in year one.

Contemporary residential home behind a green yard and trees

A landlord in Utah County has an offer on a rental she bought in 2011. The buyer wants to put 10% down and have her carry the rest on a note at 7%, and her real question is not the interest rate. It's whether the tax spreads the way the payments do, because three different pages told her depreciation recapture comes due the year she closes and eats the whole plan. Seller financing rental property taxes are better than that, and the good news arrives with an ordering rule nobody mentioned.

The rumor

Straight-line depreciation is not recapture income.

The claim is everywhere, and the statute behind it is real. IRC §453(i) recognizes recapture income in the year of the disposition and puts only the gain above it on the installment method. The trap is the definition. Section 453(i)(2) defines recapture income as the amount that would be ordinary income under §1245 or §1250, and §1250(b)(1) reaches only additional depreciation, meaning depreciation claimed above straight line. Residential rental property placed in service after 1986 is depreciated straight line over 27.5 years under §168, and no faster method is available for it. The building's §1250 recapture income is zero.

The depreciation turns into something else instead. It becomes unrecaptured §1250 gain, taxed under §1(h)(1)(E) at a maximum of 25%, and that is a capital gain rather than recapture income. Section 453(i) does not reach it. So the 15 years of depreciation that nearly killed her deal spreads across the note with the rest of the gain.

The ordering rule

The 25% layer comes out of the first payments.

A sale like this produces two kinds of long-term capital gain: unrecaptured §1250 gain capped at 25%, and ordinary long-term gain at 0%, 15%, or 20%. Treas. Reg. §1.453-12 decides which one each payment carries, and the answer is the §1250 layer first, in full, before any of the cheaper gain. Sellers almost always assume a blended rate on every payment. What they get is the top of the stack early and the bottom of it late.

On a long amortizing note that is a slower trade than it sounds. Her $558,000 note at 7% over 20 years hands back only about $13,300 of principal in 2027, which recognizes roughly $9,700 of gain. At that pace her $107,000 of depreciation is not cleared until 2032, so the 15% years people carry a note to reach do not start until year seven.

Year one

What seller financing rental property taxes cost in the first year.

Here is her deal with numbers on it. She bought in 2011 for $235,000, $45,000 of that land, and has claimed $107,000 of depreciation on the building. She sells for $620,000 with $40,000 of closing costs, takes $62,000 down in December 2026, and the buyer's first monthly payment lands in January. The full stack on an ordinary cash sale is in how much tax you pay when selling a rental property.

A $620,000 seller-financed rental sale, year one
Sale price, 10% down and a 20-year note for the rest
$620,000
Selling costs
$40,000
Adjusted basis after $107,000 of straight-line depreciation
$128,000
Gross profit
$452,000
Gross profit percentage
72.9%
Cash received at closing
$62,000
Gain recognized in 2026, all of it unrecaptured §1250 gain
$45,200
Federal tax on it at 22%
about $9,900
Same sale if a study had carved out $28,000 of five-year property
about $16,300

Tax year 2026, married filing jointly, $180,000 of wages and the $32,200 standard deduction. Property owned free and clear, so no debt is assumed by the buyer and the contract price equals the sale price. Unrecaptured §1250 gain is taxed under §1(h)(1)(E) at the regular rates subject to a 25% ceiling, which here means 22%. The cost segregation line adds $28,000 of §1245 recapture recognized in full in 2026 under §453(i), pushes $8,816 of the §1250 layer up to the 25% ceiling, and crosses the $250,000 net investment income tax threshold by $2,416. Assumes no suspended passive losses and no state tax.

The 22% isn't a typo. Section 1(h)(1)(E) caps the rate on unrecaptured §1250 gain at 25%, and a cap is not a rate. Her wages leave taxable income of $147,800, the gain stacks on top, and $193,000 is still inside the 22% bracket on a 2026 joint return. The difference against 25% on $45,200 is about $1,350.

The exception

A cost segregation study puts recapture back in year one.

Section 1245 property is where the rumor comes true. There is no straight-line comparison in §1245. The recapture is the full depreciation allowed, and §453(i) recognizes all of it in the year of sale whether the buyer's check covers it or not. Had a 2011 study carved $28,000 of her purchase into five-year property, that $28,000 is ordinary income in 2026, and her year-one federal bill runs about $16,300 instead of about $9,900 on the same $62,000 of cash. Make the building bigger, the carve-out heavier, and the down payment smaller, and the tax passes the cash at closing.

Land improvements are the piece people get wrong in the other direction. A driveway or a fence is §1250 property, and bonus depreciation on it does create additional depreciation for §453(i) to accelerate. But that excess shrinks every year and reaches zero at the end of the recovery period. A driveway bonus-depreciated in 2011 and sold in 2026 has none left. One bonus-depreciated in 2025 and sold in 2027 has nearly all of it.

The losses

Suspended losses release at the speed of the gain.

If the rental has been throwing off losses you could not use, don't count on them turning up to offset the gain. Section 469(g)(3) allows them each year in the ratio that the gain recognized that year bears to the gross profit from the sale. She has $34,000 of suspended losses and recognizes 10% of her gross profit in 2026, so $3,400 comes free this year and the rest waits on payments. A cash sale would have released all $34,000 at once, and I have seen suspended passive losses worth more than the deferral the note was supposed to buy.

Before the note is signed

Three things I check.

Who the buyer is. Section 453(g) takes the installment method away entirely on a sale of depreciable property to a controlled entity, and §1239 turns the gain ordinary on top of that, so selling the rental to your own LLC on a note does the opposite of what you wanted. A child clears §453(g), but §453(e) treats a resale by that child within two years as a payment to you and accelerates the rest of the note.

Whether to elect out. Under §453(d) you can report the whole gain in 2026 and be done with it, and that's the right answer more often than people expect. An unused capital loss carryforward, an unusually low income year, or a buyer you expect to refinance inside three years all argue for taking the gain now at a rate you can see.

What the note crosses. Her sale price is over $150,000, so if her installment obligations from 2026 are still outstanding above $5,000,000 at year end she owes the §453A interest charge on the deferred tax. She's nowhere close, though someone unloading three rentals on notes in one year can get there. The note also has to carry at least the applicable federal rate, or §1274 imputes the interest and turns part of what she thinks is principal into interest income.

Frequently asked

Quick answers on this topic.

Can I use the installment method if I sell the rental to my son?

Yes. Section 453(g) shuts the installment method off only for a sale of depreciable property to a controlled entity, and a child is not one. The rule to watch is §453(e): if he resells the property within two years, his proceeds are treated as a payment to you and the rest of your deferred gain is recognized that year. A sale to your own LLC or S corporation is the one actually barred, and §1239 makes that gain ordinary.

Is seller financing a rental a red flag with the IRS?

No. The installment method is the default under IRC §453 for any sale with a payment due after the year of closing, so you have to affirmatively elect out under §453(d) to avoid it. You report it every year on Form 6252, and the year-of-sale §1245 recapture goes on Form 4797. What actually draws scrutiny is a note priced below the applicable federal rate, because §1274 then recharacterizes part of your principal as interest income.

What happens if the buyer pays the note off early?

The deferred gain comes due in the year of the payoff. Every dollar of principal you receive carries gain at your gross profit percentage, so a balloon or a refinance bunches the remainder into one year. On the $620,000 sale above at a 72.9% gross profit percentage, a payoff of a $500,000 remaining balance recognizes about $364,500 of gain that year, which is how a 20-year plan lands in the 20% bracket anyway.

Do I owe the 3.8% net investment income tax on installment payments?

Yes, on the gain recognized each year. Gain from selling a rental held in a passive activity is net investment income, and the 3.8% applies once modified AGI passes $250,000 on a joint return or $200,000 single, thresholds set in statute and never indexed for inflation. Spreading the gain is one of the few ways to keep a large sale under those lines. The seller above lands at $225,200 of 2026 MAGI and owes none.

Does the 25% depreciation rate apply to every payment?

Only until the unrecaptured §1250 gain runs out. Treas. Reg. §1.453-12 takes that layer before the rest of the gain, so the ceiling applies to the first $107,000 of gain she recognizes and nothing after it. On a 20-year amortizing note that principal comes back slowly enough that the layer is not cleared until 2032, and the 15% gain starts only then.

Real estate tax planning

Modeling the after-tax outcome before you buy.

If a cost segregation study or a 1031 exchange is on your radar, the most valuable conversation is the one before the closing. We model the numbers, coordinate the cost seg, and file the elections, so the strategy survives the IRS, not just the spreadsheet.

More from the journal