Skip to content
Mapleton, Utah
Morkel Financial & Tax Services

Estimated taxes on uneven income: you don't owe the same amount every quarter.

By Ewan Morkel, EA6 min read

The penalty under §6654 is four separate quarterly bills, and a gain that closed in November still gets measured against the installment that came due on April 15. Form 2210 Schedule AI is how you match the installments to the month the money actually arrived.

Hands opening a brown envelope with a white sheet of paper over a wooden table

A landlord closes on a rental in the second week of November and sets plenty aside for the tax. In March the preparer hands them a Form 2210 with a penalty on it, and the first underpayment is dated April 15 of the prior year, five months before anybody knew the property would sell. The money arrived in November. The penalty starts in April. It is usually avoidable, and the fix is a form most software will not reach for unless you ask.

Four bills

The estimated tax penalty is four deadlines, not one.

Most people read the penalty as interest on what they owed in April. It is not. Section 6654 sets a required annual payment, splits it into four installments of 25% each under §6654(d)(1)(A), and charges interest on each installment separately from the day it came due. For 2026 those dates are April 15, June 15, and September 15, 2026, and January 15, 2027. Pay nothing until January and you have not missed one deadline. You have missed three, and the first one has been running for nine months.

The required annual payment is the smaller of 90% of this year's tax or 100% of last year's, which becomes 110% when last year's adjusted gross income was over $150,000 ($75,000 married filing separately) under §6654(d)(1)(C). I check that prior-year figure first, because it is a known number and this year's is a guess. It also fails in exactly the case this post is about: when last year was the bigger year, 110% of it can exceed 90% of this year, and the safe harbor buys you nothing.

The default

What the regular method assumes about your year.

The default computation assumes your income showed up in four equal pieces. Withholding gets that same even treatment in your favor: under §6654(g)(1), tax withheld from wages is treated as paid in four equal parts on the four due dates no matter which paycheck it came out of. Estimated payments get no such help. A check sent on January 15 is credited on January 15, applied to the earliest unpaid installment first, and the interest on that installment runs until the money shows up.

For a steady salary that assumption is close enough. For a year with one closing in it, it is wrong, and the form that says so is Schedule AI.

Schedule AI

Estimated taxes on uneven income: what annualizing changes.

Schedule AI breaks the year into four cumulative periods: January 1 through March 31, through May 31, through August 31, and the full year. For each one you take the income you actually received, multiply by 4, 2.4, 1.5, or 1 to project a full year, compute the tax on that projection, and multiply by the applicable percentage in §6654(d)(2)(C)(ii): 22.5%, 45%, 67.5%, and 90%. The required installment becomes the smaller of that figure or the regular one. A gain that closed on November 12 lands in the fourth period only, so the first three installments get sized by the paychecks and nothing else.

Here is the landlord's year. Wages of $150,000 with $18,000 withheld, spread evenly. A rental sold November 12, 2026 for a $420,000 long-term capital gain. No estimated payments at all, because in April nobody was planning to sell. The 2025 return showed $96,000 of tax, so the prior-year safe harbor asks for $105,600, while 90% of the $90,500 of 2026 tax is $81,450. The smaller target controls, which makes last year no help whatsoever. They pay the shortfall, $63,450, on January 15, 2027.

The same $81,450, two ways to size the installments
Required annual payment (90% of $90,500 of 2026 tax)
$81,450
Cumulative required by Apr 15 / Jun 15 / Sep 15, regular method
$20,363 / $40,725 / $61,088
Cumulative required by those dates, Schedule AI
$3,452 / $6,903 / $10,355
Cumulative withholding credited by those dates (§6654(g)(1))
$4,500 / $9,000 / $13,500
Balance paid January 15, 2027
$63,450
§6654 penalty, regular method
$1,818
§6654 penalty, Schedule AI
$0

Tax year 2026, married filing jointly, standard deduction $32,200. The $90,500 of tax is $15,340 of ordinary tax on $117,800 of taxable wage income, $63,000 of long-term capital gains tax at 15% (the 2026 joint 15% bracket runs to $613,700), and $12,160 of net investment income tax under §1411. The gain is treated entirely as adjusted net capital gain; unrecaptured §1250 gain would be taxed at up to 25% under §1(h)(1)(E) and would raise the tax without changing any of the installment arithmetic. Penalty figured as simple interest from each installment date at the §6621 underpayment rates, 6% for the quarter beginning April 1, 2026 and 7% after that; the rate for the quarter beginning January 1, 2027 had not been announced when this was written and is assumed at 7%.

Three catches

What the form makes you give up.

The first is that the reduction is borrowed, not forgiven. Section 6654(d)(2)(A)(ii) recaptures it: every dollar an early installment drops by gets added back to the next one. In the table the first three installments come to $10,355 instead of $61,088, and the fourth absorbs the difference. Miss the January 15 date after annualizing and the penalty returns on a much larger number.

The second is that it is all or nothing. Use Schedule AI for any due date and you have to use it for all four, so a year that was front-loaded in the first quarter and quiet afterward can come out worse than the default. Run both before you commit.

The third is bookkeeping, and it is where this falls apart in practice. Schedule AI wants income and deductions by period, on your method of accounting, so you need to know what closed in July as against September. Cash-basis deductions count in the period you paid them. The standard deduction is the exception that catches people: you enter the full annual amount in every column rather than a quarter of it, which is why the early periods above are figured on $117,800.

Before January 15

What to do with six weeks left in the year.

If the windfall already happened, there are two levers and one of them closes first. Withholding is the better one, because §6654(g)(1) effectively backdates it: dollars added to a December paycheck count as having arrived on April 15. If anyone in the household draws a paycheck, putting extra on line 4(c) of a new Form W-4 before the last December payroll runs can cure quarters that are already late, which is the move in do I need to pay Q4 estimated taxes. That door shuts December 31.

Schedule AI is the second lever, and it stays open until you file. Check box C in Part II of Form 2210, complete the schedule, and attach it to the return. Most software will not do this on its own, and a preparer handed a shoebox in March will not have the quarterly detail to try. If you sold something in the back half of the year, say so when you hand over the file.

Where I would put the effort: check the prior-year safe harbor first, because when it works it is one number and no extra form. When last year was the bigger year, which is common right after a sale, annualizing is the cheaper path, and on a six-figure gain it earns back the hour. If the sale is still ahead of you, selling a rental in December or January is the decision that comes before this one.

Frequently asked

Quick answers on this topic.

Can I use the annualized income installment method for only one quarter?

No. If you use Schedule AI for any payment due date, the Form 2210 instructions require you to use it for all four. That matters because a year that was heavy in the first quarter and light afterward can produce a larger early installment under annualization than the flat 25% would, so you should compute both before filing the form.

Does Schedule AI reduce the tax I owe, or only the penalty?

Only the penalty. The annualized income installment method in IRC §6654(d)(2) changes how much had to be paid by each of the four due dates, not the tax on the return. Your total tax, your required annual payment, and your April balance due are all identical either way.

Will filing Form 2210 with Schedule AI trigger an audit?

I have not seen it work that way. Schedule AI is a standard part of Form 2210 and the IRS expects it from anyone with uneven income; checking box C in Part II is the mechanism the form provides. The practical risk is not examination, it is arithmetic: the schedule asks for income by period, and if your quarterly figures do not tie to the annual totals on the return, you can expect a notice recomputing the penalty.

I did not file a return last year. Can I still use the prior-year safe harbor?

No. Under IRC §6654(d)(1)(B)(ii) the prior-year option is unavailable if you did not file a return for the preceding year or if that year was not a full 12 months. In that case 90% of the current year's tax is the only target, which makes annualizing on Schedule AI more valuable, not less, when the income arrived late.

Does withholding from a December paycheck count toward the April installment?

Yes. IRC §6654(g)(1) treats income tax withheld from wages as paid in four equal installments on the four due dates, regardless of when it was actually withheld, unless you establish the actual dates. That is why adding withholding to a December paycheck can cure an April underpayment while a January estimated payment cannot.

Business tax planning

Structuring the business to keep more of it.

S-corp elections, reasonable compensation, and the QBI deduction reward planning done before the deadline, not after. We run the entity math, file the elections on time, and keep the payroll defensible, so the savings survive an exam.

More from the journal